Replacing a Cobalt-Chrome Casting with Solid Stainless Steel: What Changes, and How to Test the Fit Before Tooling
A recent request came from a small European brand that casts a palm-sized holder in cobalt-chrome (CoCr) with a local caster today and wants to move to a solid stainless steel part made in China for its next 1,000 pieces. The part clips onto a product the buyer does not make, so the fit has to be right: the buyer specified ±0.2 mm in general and ±0.1 mm on the fitting surfaces, asked for a mirror finish, accepted AISI 304 as well as 316L, and wanted about 20 samples first. Before paying for the tooling, the buyer asked us to make sure the shape is tested on the real mating product. The answers below explain what changes when a CoCr part becomes a stainless investment casting and how to run that fit test.
Questions and answers
Can a small part that is cast in cobalt-chrome today be made as a stainless steel investment casting?
Usually yes, but the design may need small changes, because CoCr casting and stainless investment casting are different processes. Cobalt-chrome parts of this size are often made by small-batch lost-wax casting with centrifugal or vacuum pouring, the same way as dental and jewellery parts. That method fills very thin sections and sharp details well, one tree at a time.
Industrial stainless investment casting (silica sol shells, gravity pouring) is built for repeatable batches and closer control of the alloy, but very thin walls, sharp internal corners and deep narrow slots fill less easily. Before quoting we check wall thickness, corner radii and where the gate can go. Where a detail cannot be cast reliably, the usual answer is to cast it slightly fuller and finish it by CNC machining, which holds ±0.01 mm on features that need it.
304 or 316L: which stainless steel should replace cobalt-chrome?
For a dry, indoor consumer part, 304 is normally enough; choose 316L for skin contact in humid or salty conditions, outdoor use or near the sea. Both are austenitic, non-magnetic in the annealed state and take a mirror polish. 316L contains molybdenum, which improves resistance to pitting from chlorides such as sweat and sea air.
Neither grade is as hard or as wear resistant as cobalt-chrome. If the part slides against another part or is clipped on and off many times, tell us: we can look at a harder grade such as 17-4PH, or at keeping the fitting surface a little fuller so it can be adjusted after the first samples.
Why not make it in brass with a steel-coloured coating?
Because it is a different product, and the buyer should decide that, not the supplier. Brass casts fine detail more easily and costs less to machine, and a nickel or PVD coating can make it look like polished steel. But it is lighter, softer, and once the coating wears through on an edge the yellow base metal shows. In the request above the buyer replied that the part must be solid steel, so the quotation stayed with solid 304. If you are open to brass, say so in the RFQ so suppliers can quote both routes side by side.
How do you test the fit before the wax tool is made?
Print the part first, check it on the real mating product, and only then cut the tool. A practical sequence is:
- We review the STL or STEP file and agree which surfaces are critical, such as the ±0.1 mm fitting faces.
- A resin 3D print of the finished part geometry is made and fitted on the mating product, ideally the exact model the buyer sells it with. The buyer can also print the same file locally and confirm the fit.
- Any change is made in the CAD file, and the file used for the tool is frozen and dated.
- The wax injection tool is made with the shrinkage allowance for the chosen alloy, and the first castings are measured on the critical faces and test-fitted again before the remaining samples are polished.
A 3D print shows whether the shape fits; it does not show the casting tolerance or the effect of polishing. That is why the critical faces are checked again on the first cast pieces, and why we may leave them slightly full so they can be finished to size.
How should a first lot of about 20 samples be planned?
Treat the 20 samples as the first production run: same tool, same alloy, same finish as the later order. The tool is made once for the part, so the samples already prove the process that the 1,000-piece order will use. Ask for these in the sample lot:
- Measurement of the critical dimensions on several pieces, not just one.
- A fit check on the mating product and photos of the finished surface.
- A material certificate (EN 10204 3.1 is available) showing the grade.
- Agreement in writing on what may still be adjusted on the tool after the samples, and what counts as approval.
Plan shipping for the samples and for the full order separately: a few kilograms of samples normally go by express courier, while 1,000 small parts may go by air freight or by express depending on the total weight and the delivery date.
What should I send for a quotation?
Send the 3D file, the critical dimensions and how the part is used.
- STEP or STL file, plus a sketch or drawing marking the fitting faces and their tolerances.
- The material you use today (for example CoCr) and which stainless grades are acceptable.
- Required finish (mirror, satin or bead blasted) and any marking.
- Sample quantity, first order quantity and the delivery country.
- Whether you can fit-test a 3D print yourself or need us to test it on the mating product.
Our production network across Guangdong, Zhejiang, Jiangsu, Shandong and Fujian includes investment casting foundries, CNC shops and polishing workshops. Send the files through our contact page and we will reply with a DFM review and quotation.
Have a drawing? Send your STEP or PDF file with quantity, material and finish. Our engineers reply within 24 business hours with DFM feedback and a quote.
Request a quote